They're Silencing Satirical Speech and Extorting the Press (And Counting on Us to Look Away)
The systematic attack on press freedom and satirical speech constitutes the primary focus of our discourse today. We delve into the recent cancellation of Stephen Colbert's show, which occurred merely three days after he publicly criticized CBS's substantial financial settlement with Donald Trump, labeling it a bribe. This event, along with the Senate's decision to withdraw critical funding for PBS and NPR, signifies a broader assault on both journalistic integrity and the protection of free expression. The implications of these actions are dire, as they threaten the very foundation of our democratic principles and the vital role of independent media in serving the public interest. I urge listeners to reflect upon the erosion of these freedoms and consider the necessary steps to defend our democratic institutions against such encroachments.
Click to Access Sources and Episode Materials
Takeaways:
- The timing of Stephen Colbert's show cancellation shortly after his critical remarks regarding CBS's financial dealings with Donald Trump raises serious questions about press freedom.
- The elimination of federal funding for public broadcasting represents a concerning pattern of undermining independent journalism, particularly affecting rural communities reliant on local news.
- The recent actions taken against satirical speech and press freedom suggest a broader strategy aimed at silencing dissent and controlling the narrative within media outlets.
- Constitutional violations arise when financial pressure is exerted on media organizations to suppress their editorial freedom, as exemplified by the settlement payment made by CBS to Trump.
- The timeline of events surrounding the Colbert cancellation and PBS funding cuts reveals a troubling pattern that appears to target independent voices and manipulate public discourse.
- It is imperative that we actively resist these attacks on media integrity and advocate for the restoration of critical funding to public broadcasting services.
Transcript
Welcome to Democracy Spark Rapid response updates where headlines meet history.
Speaker A:I'm Bonnie Ross with Democracy Spark.
Speaker A:We break down the events that don't just make news.
Speaker A:They challenge democratic norms and connect them to the authoritarian patterns outlined in On Tyranny by Timothy Snyder.
Speaker A:Today we are focusing on the systematic attack on press freedom and satirical speech.
Speaker A:Today's episode is titled They're Silencing Satirical Speech and Extorting the Press and Counting on Us to Look away.
Speaker A: ,: Speaker A:CBS claims this is purely a financial decision.
Speaker A:The timing exposes their explanation as either breathtakingly tone deaf or deliberately dishonest.
Speaker A:Paramount has been cutting costs.
Speaker A:That's true.
Speaker A:They chose to cancel the highest rated late night show in America just days after its host called out their payment to Trump as bribery.
Speaker A:This creates a chilling attack on two distinct forms of protected speech.
Speaker A:That payment settled Trump's lawsuit over CBS's news program's 60 Minutes.
Speaker A:That's real journalism protected by the First Amendment's press freedom clause.
Speaker A:Colbert's satirical criticism of that payment is also protected by the First Amendment.
Speaker A:The same week the Republican controlled Senate voted to claw back $1.1 billion in federal funding promised to PBS and NPR.
Speaker A:They voted in the early hours of Thursday morning after a 13 hour marathon voting session.
Speaker A:This is a systematic attack on both journalistic reporting and satirical speech.
Speaker A:CBS executives making deals behind closed doors while Congress votes in the dead of night.
Speaker A:CBS broadcasts over public airwaves to anyone with an antenna.
Speaker A:No Internet, cable or subscription required.
Speaker A:It's often the only news source in rural communities and small towns across America.
Speaker A:The company acquiring CBS is Skydance Media.
Speaker A:It's owned by David Ellison, whose father, Larry Ellison, is a Trump ally who will control the merged company.
Speaker A:Meanwhile, public broadcasting stations that provide emergency alerts and local news to 13 million Americans just lost their federal funding entirely.
Speaker A:Trump explicitly threatened to withhold endorsements from any Republican who didn't vote to defund PBS and npr.
Speaker A:He called them worse than CNN and MSDNC put together.
Speaker A:That's his deliberate misspelling of MSNBC to suggest they're controlled by the Democratic National Committee.
Speaker A:Let's look at the timeline.
Speaker A:Paramount paid Trump $16 million on July 2 to settle what legal experts called a frivolous lawsuit over normal editing of a Kamala Harris interview on July 14.
Speaker A:Colbert criticized this payment on his show on July 16, the Senate voted to defund public broadcasting.
Speaker A:On July 17, CBS announced Colbert's cancellation.
Speaker A:On July 18, Congress finalized the PBS cuts, eliminating $1.1 billion in funding.
Speaker A:This demands congressional investigation.
Speaker A:Yet Congress participated in the attack.
Speaker A:The public good is not represented.
Speaker A:Only those who benefit from chilling a free press and silencing satirical speech gain from these actions.
Speaker A:And to this I say, oh, hell no.
Speaker A:Public and network broadcasting journalists and local station managers and have spent decades serving their communities with integrity.
Speaker A:They provide independent news coverage, educational programming and essential public information when commercial outlets fail to serve the public interest.
Speaker A:Stephen Colbert has used his platform to speak truth to power for nearly a decade.
Speaker A:He holds officials accountable regardless of party.
Speaker A:These professionals deserve our protection, not our abandonment.
Speaker A:This is financial extortion of the press dressed up as business strategy.
Speaker A:It's a direct violation of the First Amendment.
Speaker A:Trump sued CBS News over normal journalistic editing.
Speaker A:He demanded $20 billion when Paramount needed government approval for their merger.
Speaker A:They paid him $16 million to settle his unwinnable suit.
Speaker A:Constitutionally, the government cannot use its regulatory power to financially pressure news organizations over their editorial decisions without violating First Amendment prohibitions.
Speaker A:Yet here we are with a damning timeline.
Speaker A:CBS executives George Cheeks and the Paramount board chose corporate profits over integrity and public obligation.
Speaker A:Senate Majority Leader John Thune and 50 other Republican senators voted to silence public broadcasting because their boss told them to.
Speaker A:They violated their oath to defend the Constitution.
Speaker A:This clears the way for Skydance Media to step in with their own agenda for the public airwaves.
Speaker A:When the President threatens legislators to defund broadcasters and uses merger approval as leverage for lawsuit settlements, that's not politics, it's constitutional violation.
Speaker A:Here's what they don't want us to focus on.
Speaker A:Paramount executives claim the Colbert cancellation is purely a financial decision and not related in any way to the show's performance, content or other matters happening at Paramount.
Speaker A:This is deliberate deception.
Speaker A:Colbert hosts the highest rated late night show, consistently beating his competition.
Speaker A:They're counting on us to believe this timing is coincidental.
Speaker A:Senate Republicans claim the PBS cuts are about fiscal responsibility.
Speaker A:The same Congress just approved hundreds of billions in defense spending without debate.
Speaker A:They want us to focus on alleged bias instead of the systematic silencing of independent voices serving rural and underserved communities.
Speaker A:The vulnerability exploitation is deliberate.
Speaker A:They're targeting media infrastructure that serves people with the fewest alternatives.
Speaker A:Rural communities, low income households and areas where public broadcasting provides the only local news.
Speaker A:These communities have less political power to fight back.
Speaker A:This fits the broader authoritarian pattern of using financial pressure rather than outright censorship.
Speaker A:Make independent journalism financially unsustainable.
Speaker A:Reward compliance with lucrative mergers.
Speaker A:Create conditions where self censorship becomes smart business.
Speaker A:What we deserve.
Speaker A:We deserve media companies that choose journalistic integrity over merger approvals when powerful people sue news organizations over normal editorial decisions.
Speaker A:We deserve executives who fight frivolous lawsuits in court.
Speaker A:We deserve public broadcasting that serves communities instead of political calculations.
Speaker A:Rural Americans deserve emergency alert systems that work when storms knock out cell towers.
Speaker A:Small towns deserve local news that covers city council meetings and school board decisions.
Speaker A:We deserve representatives who vote based on their constituents needs, not presidential threats.
Speaker A:We deserve senators who understand that 13 million Americans depend on public broadcasting for information.
Speaker A:We deserve a free press because the Constitution demands it.
Speaker A:The press is called the First Estate because it serves as democracy's first line of defense against government abuse.
Speaker A:In the old European system, the first Estate was the clergy, the Second Estate was the nobility, and the Third Estate was everyone else in America.
Speaker A:We made the press our first estate, the institution that holds all other powers accountable.
Speaker A:The First Amendment recognizes that democracy cannot survive without independent media capable of investigating and criticizing those in power.
Speaker A:And what we got.
Speaker A:We got media executives who paid $16 million to gain favor in business dealings with the government instead of defending normal journalism in court.
Speaker A:We got executives who canceled their most prominent critic three days after he called out their payment as bribery.
Speaker A:We got senators who voted to eliminate federal funding for public broadcasting just weeks after dead lexus floods killed 135 people and reminded us how critical public radio is for emergency alerts.
Speaker A:We got representatives who prioritized political loyalty over rural constituents who depend on public radio for weather alerts.
Speaker A:We got a president who explicitly threatened to punish any legislator who didn't vote to silence independent media.
Speaker A:This violates both the First Amendment and separation of powers.
Speaker A:We got 51 senators who followed that threat instead of honoring their constitutional oath.
Speaker A:We got the President of the United States naming his next target by saying, I hear Jimmy Kimmel is next.
Speaker A:We got the transformation of America's universal broadcast medium into a potential propaganda outlet through through threats and financial pressure.
Speaker A:We got government officials using state authority to financially punish media criticism, tacking the constitutional foundation of American democracy itself.
Speaker A:Watch for what's next.
Speaker A:The authoritarian strategy is escalating beyond financial pressure to direct content control.
Speaker A:Once Skydance completes its CBS acquisition, expect programming decisions that favor powerful interests and avoid challenging coverage.
Speaker A:Public broadcasting stations will begin going dark this fall when their federal funding disappears.
Speaker A:This starts with smaller rural stations that can't replace government support with donations.
Speaker A:Communities will lose emergency alert systems just as climate change makes severe weather more frequent and dangerous.
Speaker A:Watch for similar financial pressure on other independent media outlets.
Speaker A:Any news organization that challenges power while depending on government licenses, federal contracts, or regulatory approval, becomes vulnerable to this same extortion model.
Speaker A:How We Resist Lessons from History Timothy Snyder's On Tyranny teaches us that defending institutions requires active resistance before they're completely captured.
Speaker A:Note that resistance is always guided by lesson 20 be as courageous as you can.
Speaker A:We are not all positioned to take each of these actions.
Speaker A:Consider what you can do given your circumstances.
Speaker A:Know that for every action of resistance you engage in, you are also representing those who are not able to stand up due to vulnerability, ability, or means.
Speaker A:Lesson 1 Do not obey in advance the Colbert cancellation and PBS defunding succeed because they anticipate future pressure rather than responding to direct orders.
Speaker A:How to resist Refuse to normalize these attacks on press freedom.
Speaker A:Call your representatives at 202-243-121 and demand they restore PBS funding.
Speaker A:Contact local CBS affiliates and tell them you're watching how they respond to corporate pressure.
Speaker A:Support other late night hosts who continue speaking truth to power.
Speaker A:Share the timeline of events to help others see the coordination.
Speaker A:Lesson 6 Be wary of paramilitaries.
Speaker A:Financial pressure serves the same function as physical intimidation, silencing opposition through fear of economic destruction.
Speaker A:How to resist Support independent media financially through direct subscriptions, donations to local public radio stations, and contributions to nonprofit journalism organizations like ProPublica and the Marshall Project.
Speaker A:Make independent journalism financially sustainable so it can't be silenced through economic warfare.
Speaker A:Diversify your news sources so you're not dependent on any single outlet.
Speaker A:Lesson 8 stand out systematic attacks on press freedoms succeed when people treat them as normal business decisions and rather than constitutional violations.
Speaker A:How to resist Document and share what's happening before it gets forgotten or buried.
Speaker A:Screenshot Colbert's criticism of the Trump payment.
Speaker A:Archive articles about the timeline of events.
Speaker A:Share this information with people who don't follow politics closely.
Speaker A:Refuse to let officials frame systematic attacks as coincidental business decisions.
Speaker A:Call out the constitutional violations publicly.
Speaker A:Lesson 18 Be calm when the unthinkable arrives.
Speaker A:The systematic capture of America's universal broadcast medium and elimination of public broadcasting represents exactly the media control that destroys democracy.
Speaker A:How to resist Stay calm and focused on concrete actions rather than being paralyzed by the scope of the attack.
Speaker A:This moment requires clear thinking about what can still be saved and how to build alternative information infrastructure.
Speaker A:Channel outrage into strategic resistance rather than panic.
Speaker A:Support local journalism and community media that serve people instead of power.
Speaker A:Remember that protecting press freedom means protecting the vulnerable people who depend on independent media, most rural communities facing severe weather, immigrants needing accurate information about their rights, elderly people who rely on radio and broadcast television, and families who can't afford multiple news subscriptions.
Speaker A:When we defend journalism, we defend democracy's ability to serve everyone.
Speaker A:For your Action resources, check out the description of this audio.
Speaker A:You'll find a link to our cited sources and to subscribe to our Democracy Action tools.
Speaker A:When you subscribe, you get Truth Telling Tuesdays.
Speaker A:That's weekly advocacy templates you can copy, paste and send to your representatives in 30 seconds.
Speaker A:Plus audio versions of all the week's analysis so you can catch up while walking or commuting.
Speaker A:And good News Friday Democracy Wins and Resistance Victories delivered to your inbox to keep you going.
Speaker A:Remember, behind each analysis hours of research to deliver clear analysis without the panic.
Speaker A:$8 a month for empowerment.
Speaker A:Democracy Spark makes it quick and easy to stand up for democracy.
Speaker A:Literally just minutes of your time to help those in this fight.
Speaker A:Our efforts are inspired by Lesson eight from On Tyranny.
Speaker A:Stand out.
Speaker A:The moment you set an example, the spell of the status quo is broken and others will follow.
Speaker A:This is Bonnie, the founder of Democracy Spark, and I invite you to stay loud and stay kind.
Speaker A:Thank you for listening.
